[l]et Me Point Out That Libertarians Defend

Group Personification Obscures, Rather Than Illuminates, Important Political Questions.

Obligations May Be Universal Or Particular.

It Is Obvious That Different Individuals Require Different Things To Live Good, Healthy, And Virtuous Lives.

To Repeat, Communitarians Maintain That We Are Constituted As Persons By Our Particular Obligations, And Therefore Those Obligations Cannot Be A Matter Of Choice.

Equality Of Rights Means That Some People Cannot Simply Impose Obligations On Others, For The Moral Agency And Rights Of Those Others Would Then Be Violated.